Meghan W. wrote, "Hi Outblush, I'm a huge fan of the show, Glee and have fallen in love with Emma Pillsbury's fashion. My absolute favorite accessory is her silver, yellow and green J. Crew Penelope Mary Janes. Unfortunately they are discontinued and completely impossible to find on eBay in my size, 9.5. If you could find any possible substitutes for my dream shoes, you would make my day! Thanks, Meghan"
Damn you, J. Crew! Quite possibly, some of the cutest shoes ever... and you discontinue them? That's just... grrr. Well, we searched high and low for Mary Janes, color block pumps, and spectator pumps, and found six shoes that might work. Let us know how we did!
1 - DKNYC Women's Claudine Mary Jane Pump ($54 on sale, only left in 9.5!)
2 - Sergio Rossi Spectator Mary Jane Pump ($200)
3 - Luna Rosa Women's Carole Maryjane ($52)
4 - John Fluevog Women's Pearl Hart Mary Jane Pump ($209, in 6 color combos)
5 - Rockabilly Colorblock Pumps ($55)
6 - Sergio Rossi Patent & Suede Mary Jane ($200)
Frustrated in your search for that perfect leather handbag, red stiletto pump, or whatever makes your heart go thump in the night? Send us a request and we might do the shopping work for you in a future Personal Shopper feature!