Biting into a pair of Cookies and Marshmallow Eye Balls ($12, for 4) from the geniuses at Tumbador Chocolate is like handing over a one-way ticket to the nostalgia train. Err, at least, for the thirty or so seconds it takes you to devour them! Each eyeball tastes like a gourmet version of a marshmallow fluff sandwich dipped in heavenly dark chocolate. Plus, the clever bloodshot eye-ring is gruesome in a way only your inner child can appreciate. If we had the means, we'd hand out a pack of eyes to all of our trick-or-treaters. Except for the group of teens that comes to our door sans costume. No costume, no candy!